Empire Builder accident (9/25/21)

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
This is the exact reason that all Amtrak diners and lounge cars have to have booth seating or chairs bolted to ground. Also why the coffee makers have to be installed.
Mhm, but also all the plates, food in the kitchen and up top. And they should've been in dinner service too.
 
Looking at my GPS tracklogs from my last two trips through there...at Buelow we were travling about 70 on one trip and 78 on the other.
Here is Buelow on Google maps...
https://www.google.com/maps/place/B...8bac73bdf7cdfc!8m2!3d48.5597119!4d-110.837186

That’s what I was thinking. I’m guessing the diner picked the switch and the whiplash force sent those last few cars over and broke the coupler.

The lounge probably got dragged along a bit before ending up on its side.

That type of force at 79 mph would be really bad.
 
Last edited:
The Superliners are an amazing piece of engineering and my hats off to the Pullman engineers that found a way to keep the CG so low in a tall car. But on an embankment, physics again takes over. The unfortunate thing about sitting 16 feet in the air, further to the ground when rolling over.

The cars separating is concerning, that is why Amtrak trains have stronger couplers than freight cars, you want to cars to stay together,

Saddened about the three fatalities, condolences and sympathies to their families that will receive the bad news.
 
So it look like the SSL and the two coach cars are on their sides and quite a ways back from the rest of the train and sleeper/dining cars stayed upright? Yikes.

The diner is partially derailed but upright. The SSL is on its side behind the diner.

The rest of the Portland section is on its side and seperate from the train.

(I’m just stating what it appears to me in the photos - I may have missed something)
 
I forgot this is the empire builder consist... what I was calling the diner might have been a coach. Don’t they usually have the Seattle coaches between the diner and ssl?
 
Deep sadness when Amtrak is working so hard to survive.

https://www.cnn.com/2021/09/25/us/amtrak-train-derailed-montana/index.html
(CNN)Three people are dead after an Amtrak train derailed in Montana on Saturday afternoon, the Liberty County Sheriff's office said in a statement to CNN.
Authorities would not speak on the number of injured or the extent of their injuries.
A statement from the railway said five cars from Amtrak's Empire Builder train 7/27 derailed near Joplin, Montana, injuring an undisclosed number of passengers.

MODERATOR NOTE: edited because of copyright regulations
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The diner is partially derailed but upright. The SSL is on its side behind the diner.

The rest of the Portland section is on its side and seperate from the train.

(I’m just stating what it appears to me in the photos - I may have missed something)

Oh, wow. I feel a little weird thinking about this because if I was on this train, I'd have been in the cars that were still upright. (I'm along the Seattle route.) Yikes.
 
Horrible news. And those photos. We always tell ourselves that the train is the safest way to travel, and it's true, but that only makes it more disturbing when something like this happens. How many times have we all banged over a switch at 79 mph?
 
Last edited:
I forgot this is the empire builder consist... what I was calling the diner might have been a coach. Don’t they usually have the Seattle coaches between the diner and ssl?
Yep, they do. Usually two but this train only had one due to covid.

Oh, wow. I feel a little weird thinking about this because if I was on this train, I'd have been in the cars that were still upright. (I'm along the Seattle route.) Yikes.
This is the typical consist for trains 27/7 and 28/8

Two engines
Baggage
Trans dorm
1-2 Seattle sleepers
Diner
1-2 Seattle coaches
Lounge

1-2 Portland coaches
1 Portland sleeper


Everything in italics derailed, everything in bold was turned on it's side in this wreck.
 
Back
Top