amtrakmichigan said:
I asked him about the new rule and he said basically that it cant be over 50lbs." ONLY IF AN AMTRAK EMPLOYEE HANDLES IT ". (conductor, coach or sleeper attendent or baggage people or redcaps) however he went on to say that if your willing to carry it yourself and handle it yourself, then that's your business.
Sure the rule is to protect the employees, but it still strictly prohibits ANY carry on baggage of over 50 lbs, regardless of who handles it. The rule is also in place to ensure that heavy, bulky items are not onboard and a nuisance if the train needed to be evacuated for some reason. It is an all-around rule, and I HAVE seen conductors (especially this Thanksgiving weekend) refuse passengers boarding because their bags were obviously way too heavy, even though the passengers planned on carrying their own bags the entire trip. So beware, 50 lbs max all around, checked or carry on. If your bag is heavier than that you can just break it up into more bags.